BlogJams Peanut Butter Sandwich or Fluffernutter? Vote Now

Some debates just hit different. Red snappers vs. Italian sandwiches. Moxie vs. who-knows-what. But there’s one matchup that’s been quietly dividing lunchboxes across generations here in Maine: the good ol’ Jams Peanut Butter Sandwich versus the legendary Fluffernutter.

Now before anyone gets riled up, let me say this: there’s no wrong answer here. We’re not talking politics—we’re talking peanut butter. And whether you lean team jam or team fluff, this is about celebrating two iconic Maine memories, one bite at a time.

A Nod to the Jams Peanut Butter Sandwich

Let’s start with the classic. There’s something downright wholesome about a peanut butter and jam sandwich. The kind you’d find tucked into your lunchbox by mom before heading off to school—or packed up for a day at camp down by the lake.

Now we’re not talking store-brand jelly here—we’re talking real Maine-made jams. Wild blueberry, raspberry, or strawberry rhubarb if you’re feeling adventurous. Paired with a generous swipe of peanut butter on homemade bread? That’s a little slice of Maine childhood right there.

If you’re like me, you might even grill it for that golden crisp crust and gooey middle. It’s the kind of sandwich that makes you feel like you’re back in Grammy’s kitchen, sneaking a second helping while she pretends not to notice.

And Then There’s the Fluffernutter…

Now for the sweet tooths out there—enter the Fluffernutter. Peanut butter meets marshmallow fluff, a combo that sounds like something invented by a sugar-crazed kid (and probably was). But let me tell you, it works. And it works real good.

It’s gooey, it’s sticky, and it’s pure comfort food. Some say it’s a dessert pretending to be a sandwich. I say it’s a piece of Maine history. Heck, we’re proud to say that marshmallow fluff has deep New England roots, and the Fluffernutter is basically our region’s answer to s’mores.

When my kids come in after a long Little League practice, red-faced and hungry, a Fluffernutter sandwich and a glass of cold milk still does the trick. Instant smiles. Full bellies. Sticky fingers and all.

If you’re craving that classic Maine flavor, you don’t have to wait—grab all the ingredients, including our favorite peanut butter and marshmallow fluff, right now at Box of Maine. We’ll help you bring a little taste of home to your table.

️ So… Which One Wins?

This is where you come in.

We’re calling on all proud Mainers, former Mainers, and Maine-lovers across the country to cast your vote:

• Team Jam – Sweet, tangy, nostalgic

• Team Fluff – Gooey, playful, undeniably Maine

Head to our Instagram or Facebook and drop your vote in the comments! Or better yet—send a care package to a friend and let them decide! (Hint: we’ve got some wicked good jams and marshmallow fluff at Box of Maine).

❤️ Why We Love Both

At the end of the day, whether you’re jammin’ or fluffin’, it’s all about the memories. These sandwiches are more than lunch—they’re a taste of home. They remind us of simpler times, of after-school snacks and summer picnics, of making do with what we had—and turning it into something special.

If you want to satisfy your sweet tooth even more, check out our recent blog on Delicious Maine Desserts You Can’t Miss. It’s packed with treats that celebrate the flavors and spirit of Maine.

So whichever side you’re on, remember this: Maine pride tastes good either way.

Now pass the napkins, would ya?

From my family to yours, keep celebrating the little things—because sometimes, the best memories come between two slices of bread.

God bless,
Dan
Owner, Box of Maine