BlogNutella & Marshmallow or Fluffernutter? Vote Now

Ring the Bell: Nutella & Marshmallow vs Fluffernutter

Ladies and gentlemen, grab your gloves—and maybe a napkin—because today’s showdown is sticky, sweet, and downright delicious. In the red corner, we have the classic New England champion: Fluffernutter—peanut butter and marshmallow fluff on white bread. And in the blue corner, the challenger: Nutella & Marshmallow Sandwich—rich chocolate-hazelnut spread meets marshmallow fluff in a modern mashup.

It’s a battle between tradition and twist. Place your bets. Let’s get ready to rumble—or simply munch!

Round 1: Fluffernutter – The Maine Legend

This is more than just a sandwich. It’s a piece of New England culinary folklore. Born in Massachusetts in the early 1900s, Fluffernutter evolved from the Liberty Sandwich to a branded cult classic by the 1960s.

• Simple & nostalgic: peanut butter + marshmallow creme on soft white bread

• Flexible: many Mainers toast it, add banana, honey, or even bacon for an upscale spin

• Culture cornerstone: there’s even a National Fluffernutter Day (October 8) and Fluff Fest in Somerville, OH

When I think of this sandwich, I’m picturing lunchboxes, campfires, and wide grins. That gooey middle? Pure childhood in every bite.

Round 2: Nutella & Marshmallow – The Bold Challenger

Here’s where the gloves get fancy. The Nutella & Marshmallow Sandwich supercharges classic fluff with chocolate-hazelnut spread.

• Decadent combo: smooth Nutella pairs beautifully with fluffy marshmallow for contrast in both flavor and texture.

• Grilled or toasted: buttered bread in a skillet gives a crispy exterior with a molten center—just magic.

• Creative power-up: kid-approved, dessert-flavored, and totally indulgent without fuss.

It’s a modern twist that feels grown-up yet familiar—like Maine meets Europe meets your childhood.

⚖️ Final Round: Who Wins?

Let’s break it down the old-fashioned way—bite by bite.

When it comes to legacy and nostalgia, the Fluffernutter has the home-court advantage. This sandwich is steeped in New England history, a staple of childhood lunchboxes across generations. It’s the kind of thing that brings back memories of simpler times, when peanut butter and fluff were just about the best thing that could happen to a slice of white bread.

Now, Nutella & Marshmallow may not have the same historical roots around here, but it’s no slouch in the nostalgia department either. That creamy, chocolate-hazelnut flavor reminds many folks of after-school snacks and European-inspired treats. Paired with fluff? It’s a modern twist that still feels familiar.

As for flavor, the Fluffernutter delivers that unbeatable sweet-and-salty combo: rich peanut butter meets sweet, airy marshmallow. It’s balanced, comforting, and never too fancy. The Nutella & Marshmallow pairing leans sweeter—decadent, smooth, and just a touch luxurious. The chocolatey hazelnut spread plays beautifully with the fluff’s vanilla notes.

Preparation-wise, both are easy to whip up, but Nutella lovers often take it to the next level by toasting or grilling it for a warm, melty middle and crispy edges. The Fluffernutter doesn’t need much fuss—spread, press, done—but it’s also great toasted if you want a little crunch.

When it comes to family favorites, the Fluffernutter has a solid reputation as a Maine classic. It’s the sandwich equivalent of a warm hug after a long day. And if you’re ready to relive those comforting bites—or introduce someone to this sticky, sweet slice of New England—you can order our Fluffernutter Box right from Box of Maine. It includes everything you need to make the perfect fluff-filled sandwich at home, no matter where you are.

The Nutella & Marshmallow version may be the new kid on the block, but there’s always room in the lunchbox for both.

Final Bell: The Winner?

Here’s the thing—this isn’t a match to see who’s better. It’s a celebration of two contenders, each bringing something sweet to the ring. Whether you’re team Fluffernutter for its heritage or rooting for the Nutella & Marshmallow combination for its chocolatey flair, both sandwiches taste like home.

Feeling Inspired? Bring the champ to your kitchen!

We carry all the staples—fluffy Marshmallow Fluff, creamy peanut butter, rich Nutella, and Maine-made spreads—ready to ship from Box of Maine. Feeling nostalgic—or feeling adventurous? We’ve got you covered.

Want More Maine-Sweetness Beyond the Ring?

Check out our latest blog on 4th of July 2025 Desserts berry flag cake, whoopie pies, and more homegrown treats await!

From my table to yours: in Maine, a little sweetness is always a win.

Dan
Owner, Box of Maine